Sunday, September 11, 2011

The Ustream Audio Issue Resolution


Since I spent pretty much the entire day trying to figure that out, as well as going to a few other services before hand I decided I might as well write about it. It turned out to be quite a stressful experience that I'm glad I'm finished with.

The entire story of the experience is quite a long one, but it came down to that I was just looking for a streaming service that would allow me to stream in the first place and be fairly coherent with the hindrance of my not really great PC. The first thing that came to mind as usual was Procaster which Alice and I used frequently for other games, and it actually worked fairly well on my old PC too, but evidently that PC had more processing power than my current one, and I experienced more than a few problems. To start off with, I was trying out the new Procaster that completely shuts off when a computer is above using it's threshold of 80% or higher CPU processing power, so since my computer was constantly at that limit, I wasn't even able to get the stream to start. I didn't give up there however , I instead reverted to a old version of Procaster that Alice and I used to stream games that weren't enabled on Xfire in the past, however that didn't work too well either, the sound was stutter and it made my system lag to near in-playability, I also experienced stutters with the sound on my computer as well, so that wasn't exactly ideal. With all of that, it made me renew my quest to find out a new streaming service that would allow me to broadcast fairly easily.

The first one that I came across and I had tried to set up in the past was Ustream, and as I understand, Ustream is a pretty popular streaming service for non-gamers, but some gamers did find out a way anyway to use it for our purpose. A very long time ago I followed a guide about setting it up for gaming and I completed the process about halfway until it gets to a part where it literally says to buy a external program to allow sound to come through onto the broadcast. I didn't want to do that of course so I stopped there, coming back to the Ustream service after all of this time, I still encountered that problem of course, and it was a headache to solve, in fact it took pretty much all day. I read many different guides saying to try out different programs, and some even said to enable microphones but I found out that was more for enabling chat programs such as Skype, Ventrilo, and Team Speak rather than what I was trying to get, so I ignored many of those guides and I really couldn't find any hints on what to do. This resulted in me giving up on Ustream once again and trying to go to another service, since I've played a lot of League of Legends recently I've heard of Own3d streaming, so of course that was my next stop. When I got there I literally registered once and then it said to download a streaming program that is in beta at which point I had to register again, however every time I tried to register it didn't process and I did try almost every possible alternative such as changing my password or user name but it still didn't go through, to make it even more annoying it didn't actually give me a reason why my action didn't happen. So of course, I gave up on that, last but not least we have Justin.tv, again, I heard a lot of good things about the service however, I don't like that it uses it's own program for desktop and game streaming that gives 10 free uses and then forces a charge. It also offers free webcam streaming like Ustream, but that didn't help as it led me back to my soundless problem, and I decided I prefer Ustream to Justin.tv anyway so I left that idea behind.

That brings us back to Ustream, after doing some tests on Procaster again and deciding that it was just too unstable and more annoying than fun, Ustream was basically the only option I could think of, so I just had to get sound working. To my luck I did a few more searches and finally came upon a answer that seemed pretty good, it was on a post from someone having the same problem as I was, and it was answered by a moderator, it of course said to go to another page where the question was already answered but the mod's answered in a very helpful fashion. While they did say to go to another page they did identify the problem, and on the other page the problem was finally fixed as I found out I had to enable a disabled device that prevented my computer audio devices to be selected. So for future reference and for anyone that reads my blogs, I would like to point this part out because it was very helpful, and just in general, while the process of getting computer streaming on Ustream to begin with is a hassle, I think if Procaster or some other stream isn't working out for you, Ustream can be a fairly good alternative.


1.)You need a video device that would allow redirection of the desktop to the broadcast, I personally use Manycam which is a webcam with desktop footage options. Ustream has also thought of this problem and has released it's own desktop viewer called Ustream Producer, and while it's not only for the desktop or it's primary purpose might not be that at all, it definitely would allow you to stream your Desktop.

2.)As for audio this part is the part that really confused me, unlike what some guides say, you don’t really need to do anything special. In order to literally get computer audio (not microphone or anything like that audio) you need to do this : go onto the sound window in control panel then go into recording and make sure “Show disabled devices” is enabled, afterward all that's left to do is enable “Stereo mix”, and that solved the problem easily. It's a simple thing but it for the untechnical savvy such as myself, it was probably one of the things I would try in a couple of years rather than now.


After that you should be good to go, I believe enabling a microphone goes through the same process as enabling the stereo mix but instead it just is through different ports.

In conclusion, I haven't tried to broadcast what I wanted to do yet, but so far Ustream is far more compatible with a low end computer like mine than Xfire, or Procaster, and it allows me to stream where I wouldn't be able to, to begin with, so for that I'm thankful, and while I'm sure the stream won't be the best quality in the world, I'm just happy to finally be able to have audio on Ustream.

No comments:

Post a Comment